links

title

Pachter's Pointers:
Business Etiquette Tips & Career Suggestions


6.21.2016

Do you agree with “No, I Agree”?

Why does my manager say “No, I agree” – when she agrees with me? It doesn’t make any sense to start with a “no.”

This question from a seminar participant reminded me that I have meant to discuss this communication conundrum for some time.

The above manager who confuses my seminar participant is using what I call a “contradictory phrase.” This is a term frequently used to describe an expression where the first part seems to contradict the second, as in “organized chaos” or “original copies.” This type of wording is sometimes called an oxymoron, and is often intentionally used for humor or to create rhetorical effect. Examples include “pretty ugly” or “sweet sorrow.”

However, this article is not about crafting such wording for literary effect. This is about the specific use of “no” as the first part of a phrase, followed by wording that seems contradictory. As illustrated above, this can occur when someone agrees with you by saying, “No, I agree.” It also pops up when someone tells you that you are correct by saying, “No, you’re right.” Other examples include, “No, I’m certain,” “No, you’re fine,” and “No, I’m sure.” 

This is a kind of verbal idiosyncrasy that many people don’t notice – but once they become aware of its use, it can drive them crazy.

So why do people use these types of phrases? Based upon my research, I have come up with three reasons:

Sometimes these phrases are said sarcastically, such as on this ecard that’s part of the humorous “rotten” series: No, you’re right. Let’s do it the dumbest way possible because it’s easier for you. 

Or, the person says “no” as part of an unspoken addition to a comment, such as “No, I don’t disagree with that. I agree.” The other person is supposed to know what was left unsaid and fill in the blanks. And sometimes in casual conversation that will happen. But not always.

And sometimes people just say “no” as a matter of course. There are some people who have a tendency to respond negatively to any comment or request – at least at first. I admit that I did that when my son was young. Saying “no” immediately gave me a second to evaluate what he wanted, before I (sometimes) agreed to his request. I found myself making comments such as, “No. [slight pause] You can sleep over at Max’s house.” When I realized how often I was saying things like that, I stopped saying “no” and replaced it with the phrase “Let me think about it.”

Other solutions to eliminating these types of contradictory phrases include:
  • Eliminate the “no.” Simply state your response. Instead of saying, “No, you’re right,” say, “You’re right.” It’s a more positive comment.
  • Explain the unspoken.  Instead of saying, “No, you’re fine,” you would clarify, “No, I don’t think you’re inappropriately dressed. You’re fine.”

Additional information on communication can be found in my book The Essentials of Business Etiquette: How to Greet, Eat, and Tweet Your Way to Success. 

Pachter & Associates provides seminars and coaching on communication, business writing, presentation skills, professional presence, and etiquette. For additional information, please contact Joyce Hoff at  joyce@pachter.com or 856.751.6141. 


Image courtesy of photostock at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

52 comments:

  1. Of course, no need to use the word "no" in combination with positive words. It makes no sense. If you have any doubt regarding to the essay writing, you can go through the law essay writing service. It will act as the complete guidance for your writing works.

    ReplyDelete
  2. your blog is really very much interesting thus it is very much useful and it has many ideas and views in this blog it is really good.


    Salesforce Training in Chennai Adyar

    ReplyDelete
  3. you have such a great blog!! and I love this article about "Do you agree with “No, I Agree”?...thanks for sharing!!

    carol @ ONLINE PhD UK programs

    ReplyDelete
  4. In today’s competitive business world and difficult economy, effective communication skills training is more essential than ever before. It is the foundation on which companies and careers are built and a crucial component of lasting success.Find best Communication Skill training centers in your locality at UrbanPro.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your valuable information. We strive to provide our candidates with excellent care and we take your comments to heart.As always, we appreciate your confidence and trust in us.


    Base SAS Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is a great post. I like this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways.Thanks for posting this again.

    Digital Marketing For Small Business in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  7. Your ways great helped him in business thanks for share it personal statement business studies .

    ReplyDelete
  8. The more you shall honor Me,
    The more I shall bless you.
    -the Infant Jesus of Prague

    trustNjesus, dear, and wiseabove.
    Meet me Upstairs.
    Let's getta Big-Ol beer...
    gotta lotta tok about.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'm not absolutely sure, because I don't care about such things, but if you ask http://prowriterscenter.com/ to answer, they'll explain it absolutely clearly.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for sharing this valuable information to our vision. You have posted a trust worthy blog keep sharing

    monkey go happy | superfighters 2 | bloons td | happy wheels 3

    ReplyDelete
  11. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.

    defend your nuts 2 | atari breakout | atari breakout game | cat mario

    ReplyDelete
  12. click here to get maharashtra ssc result 2017

    ReplyDelete
  13. Super Bowl LI will be the 51st Super Bowl and the 47th modern-era National Football League .... The Touchdown Tour is a way to excite the Houston community about the 2016-2017 football season culminating in Super Bowl LI.
    Super Bowl 51
    Super Bowl 51 Live
    Super Bowl 51 Live Stream
    Watch Super Bowl 51
    Watch Super Bowl 51 Live
    Super Bowl 51 Live Online

    ReplyDelete
  14. Click here to get karnataka sslc result 2017.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Students can check TN HSC Result at official website.

    ReplyDelete
  16. We posted this topic information was really well.The content of this topic was the strength is high level.Many helping for our post.Selenium Training in Chennai | Best Selenium Automation Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  17. I often get emotionally involved. Like when I read your post, I can cry, laugh, sad, funny, depending on your written words. I think you are a sensitive person.
    facebook baixar l baixar facebook gratis l baixar whatsapp gratis l baixar whatsapp plus

    ReplyDelete
  18. UFC 209: Woodley vs. Thompson 2 is an upcoming mixed martial arts event produced by the Ultimate Fighting Championship that will be held on March 4, 2017. Event information, results, video, and fighter information for UFC 209

    UFC 209


    UFC 209 Fight Card


    UFC 209 Live


    UFC 209 Live Stream


    UFC 209 Start Time


    UFC 209


    UFC 209 Live

    ReplyDelete
  19. UFC lightweight Marc Diakiese is putting out a strong message of tolerance and acceptance, become the first fighter for the world's largest MMA. CONOR McGREGOR has been pictured with Manchester United star Wayne Rooney as talks of a superfight with Floyd Mayweather rumble on.
    UFC 209
    UFC 209 Live , UFC 209 Fight Card
    UFC 209 Live Stream , UFC 209 Fight

    RONDA ROUSEY was battered by Amanda Nunes in her long-awaited UFC comeback bout - here are some of the best pictures from the fight. Born in Sweden, Hermansson (14-3) looks to bounce back from his first UFC loss, a submission defeat to Cezar Ferreira that snapped .
    UFC 209
    UFC 209 Live Stream , UFC 209 Live
    UFC 209 Fight , UFC 209 Fight Card

    ReplyDelete
  20. In all actuality a low FICO assessment has little effect on any credit endorsement methodology. Of much more enthusiasm to a home loan supplier is whether the candidate has a decent and secure employment, and if the measure of obligation they as of now have is too high or not. https://www.usapaydayloanstore.com/chicago

    ReplyDelete
  21. Following having a few times with mid-major March Madness championship video games claiming the college or universityMarch Madness Live golf ball spotlight, the Power 5 March Madness Live Stream conference tournaments learn to take center stage today. These kinds of are the games that will help define how a bubble and the rear end of the NCAA March Madness Bracket Tournament bracket shakes away.
    March Madness 2017
    On Wednesday, Syracuse, Arkansas, March Madness 2017 Live California, TCU, Ohio Point out, Wake Forest, 2017 March Madness Virginia Technical, Texas Tech, Xavier and El monte all play game titles NCAA March Madness that will either help solidify their at-large berth/seed or make Selection Weekend more of an stressed day. march madness schedule

    One other quick note: I moved Gonzaga back up to the top seed line after a third thoroughly impressive win over a very good Saint Mary's team in the WCC subject game. That's not complete, though. The Pac-12 event champion march madness schedule 2017 could easily find yourself there by the end of the week, particularly if the winner of the Arizona/UCLA semifinal beats Or in it game.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Following having a few times with mid-major March Madness championship game titles claiming the college or universityMarch Madness Live field hockey spotlight, the Power 5 March Madness Live Stream conference tournaments learn to take center stage today. These types of are the games that will help define the way the bubble and the rear end of the NCAA March Madness Bracket Tournament bracket shakes away.
    March Madness 2017
    On Wednesday, Syracuse, New mexico, March Madness 2017 Live California, TCU, Ohio Express, Wake Forest, 2017 March Madness Virginia Technology, Texas Tech, Xavier and El monte all play video games NCAA March Madness that will either help solidify their at-large berth/seed or make Selection On the more of an stressed day. march madness schedule

    One other quick note: I moved Gonzaga back up to the top seed line after a third thoroughly impressive win over a very good Saint Mary's team in the WCC name game. That's not overall, though. The Pac-12 event champion march madness schedule 2017 could easily end up there by the end of the week, particularly if the winner of the Arizona/UCLA semifinal beats Or in it game.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I am certain there are millions of more pleasant intance ahead for individuals who discover your blog.bhavika sharma

    ReplyDelete
  24. Click here to get HSC Result Gujarat at official website.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Today much too much time is spent working, and many people find that they have little or no time to spend with those that they love. Furthermore, there are other reasons as to why so many people now choose to set up an online business. Best digital marketing classes in chennai

    ReplyDelete